We bake handcrafted cookies that spread joy, bring people together, and give back to causes close to our hearts.
Some of the Celebrations in May: Teacher Appreciation, Mother's Day, Nurses Day, Memorial Day and Armed Forces Day, Communions and Graduations
Menu / Price List
Custom Cookie Sets
College Bound Set
$60
Set of 12 Large Cookies
2 -banners with college design
2- balloon set with college colors
2- string banner with Congratulations
1 - Congratualtions Balloon Arch
5 -College Image and design
Communion Set
$60
Set of 12 Large Cookies
2 - Gold Cross
3- Gold Cross w/Dove
2- God Bless with name
2- Rosary Beads
3- Gold Chalice
Mother's Day
$60
Set of 12 Large Cookies
2 - Bouquet
2-Mom Banner
2- Tulip Arrangement
2- Sending appreciation envelope
2- Daisy Cookies
2- MOM Cookies
Teacher/School Staff Appreciation
$5 each
- Apple with personalized name
- Personalized Name Plate with apple
- Personalized Name Plate with pencil
- Personalized "Run on Coffee" mug
- Personalized Large Pencil with notebook paper
Nurse Set (2 Large cookies)
$10
1- RN shirt
1- Heart with heart beat and personalized name
Military Branch Cookies
TBD
Call for Custom Military Branch Cookie Sets
Custom Cookie Sets
Custom Sets
TBD
Call anytime to discuss custom sets and pricing.
Home Set
$30
6 cookies each individually wrapped
(1) Welcome Mat
(1) Door
(1) House
(1) sold sign with your custom logo
(1) Key
(1) image of home
Please email below or text/call 516-779-0883 to discuss ordering a custom set today
About The Uncommon Cookie
Our Ingredients
Packaging and Pick-Up
Packaging and Pick-Up
- Sugar, Salted Butter, Egg, Vanilla, Salt, Flour, Meringue Powder, Powdered Sugar, Corn Syrup, Food Coloring.
- Frosting sheets on specialty orders. Sugar
Corn syrup solids, Modified food starch, Maltodextrin, Vegetable oil , Glycerin, Water, Cellulose gum, Xanthan gum, Sodium propionate, Titanium dioxide , Artificial or natural flavor - Each
- Sugar, Salted Butter, Egg, Vanilla, Salt, Flour, Meringue Powder, Powdered Sugar, Corn Syrup, Food Coloring.
- Frosting sheets on specialty orders. Sugar
Corn syrup solids, Modified food starch, Maltodextrin, Vegetable oil , Glycerin, Water, Cellulose gum, Xanthan gum, Sodium propionate, Titanium dioxide , Artificial or natural flavor - Each cookie is crafted with love so please understand there may be slight variations to each cookie (including color) due to the handmade nature .Cookies may vary in size between 3"-4" and are rolled 3/8 " thick.
Packaging and Pick-Up
Packaging and Pick-Up
Packaging and Pick-Up
- All cookies are individually sealed in clear bags, labeled with ingredients and packaged with care. They will stay fresh for weeks so no fridge needed.
- Pick up or delivery will be discussed upon order placement.
- Payment must be made in full 24 hours after receipt of invoice or order will be cancelled. Please reach out ASAP if you have an issue with payment.
Made in a Home Kitchen
Made in a Home Kitchen
Made in a Home Kitchen
FOOD ALLERGY ALERT
- All products are produced in a home kitchen containing known food allergens, including, but not limited to: eggs, wheat, soy, milk, peanuts, and tree nuts and all of the products contain some of these allergens.
- Customers order has been made in a home kitchen not required to have a food inspection.
Baking With Purpose
Made in a Home Kitchen
Made in a Home Kitchen
- At The Uncommon Cookie, we believe sweetness should extend beyond the cookie. A portion of our proceeds is donated to The Anchor Program Fund and Blue Star Moms, two organizations that are deeply meaningful to our family. We invite you to visit their websites to learn more about their missions and the incredible impact they make.
- https://www.campanchor.org/
- https://www.bluestarmoms.org/